Community Voices — Travis Graham: The state of public education in Missouri: A crossroads for our schools and communities

As I reflect on the current condition of public education in Missouri, I find myself increasingly concerned — not simply about the financial challenges facing our schools, but about the direction of public education itself. 

After years of serving students, supporting educators, working alongside families, and navigating the complexities of school leadership, I believe we are approaching a defining moment in the history of public education in our state.

The questions before us extend far beyond test scores, accountability systems, and school budgets. They challenge the very foundation of what public education represents, particularly for small rural communities where the local school district is not simply an educational institution but a cornerstone of community identity, opportunity, and economic stability.

Are we genuinely working to improve public education, or are we witnessing the gradual deconstruction of the very system Missouri has a constitutional responsibility to maintain?

I do not pose this question lightly, nor do I suggest that every decision being made in Jefferson City is part of a coordinated effort to dismantle public schools. However, when we examine the cumulative effects of funding decisions, leadership changes, new accountability expectations, and increasing financial pressures, we must consider where this trajectory could ultimately lead.

The State Board of Education: Leadership, transparency and public trust

Missouri’s State Board of Education was established to provide stability, continuity, and a degree of independence from the political pressures that naturally accompany changes in elected leadership. Its responsibility is to oversee and support a public education system that serves students across our state, regardless of geographic location, economic circumstance, or political affiliation.

Recent developments have raised important questions about the independence, transparency and priorities of that governing body.

The departure of Commissioner Karla Eslinger, followed by the October 2026 resignation of Interim Commissioner Stacey Preis after only four months, has created a period of significant leadership transition. At the same time, Governor Mike Kehoe has had the opportunity to appoint a substantial majority of the State Board’s membership.

These developments do not, by themselves, demonstrate improper conduct. Nevertheless, they underscore the importance of maintaining public confidence in the independence of educational governance.

Additional questions emerged surrounding the use of private philanthropic funding for the search for Missouri’s next Commissioner of Education and the development of the State Board’s strategic plan. While private contributions may reduce direct taxpayer expenditures, the public deserves transparency regarding who is funding efforts that could influence the future direction of public education. The subsequent identification of funding organizations is an important development, but transparency must extend to the processes, expectations, and safeguards governing those relationships.

Public education is a public responsibility. Its direction should be determined through transparent processes that place the interests of Missouri’s children above all other considerations.

Perhaps even more concerning is the apparent disconnect between the expectations being placed upon public schools and the financial resources being requested to support them.

In September 2026, the State Board of Education declined to request approximately $300 million in additional funding needed to fully fund Missouri’s school foundation formula for the coming fiscal year. Instead, the Board elected to maintain a flat funding request despite increasing costs and the requirements established by state law.

I recognize that Missouri faces legitimate budget constraints and that requesting additional funding does not guarantee legislative appropriation. Nevertheless, there is an important distinction between acknowledging fiscal realities and fully communicating the financial needs of public education.

If the very body charged with overseeing Missouri’s public schools does not advocate for the resources calculated under the state’s own funding formula, who will?

The A–F report card: Accountability without adequate support?

Governor Kehoe’s Executive Order 26-01 introduced a new A–F school and district grading framework intended to provide parents and communities with a clearer understanding of school performance.

Let me be clear: I believe in accountability. I believe in high expectations, measurable student growth, instructional improvement, and transparency. At Purdy R-II, our district vision is Excellence is the Standard, and we take that commitment seriously.

However, accountability must be accompanied by the capacity to improve.

Missouri already operates an extensive accountability system through the Missouri School Improvement Program, Annual Performance Reports, state assessments, graduation measures, and other performance indicators. The addition of an A–F rating system raises a fundamental question: Are we providing schools with meaningful tools to improve student learning, or simply creating another mechanism for labeling their performance?

The proposed framework incorporates academic achievement, student growth, literacy, graduation rates, and college and career readiness measures. These are important indicators. However, no single letter grade can adequately communicate the full complexity of educating children.

A letter grade cannot fully capture the challenges of educating students living in poverty, supporting children with disabilities, serving English language learners, addressing chronic absenteeism, or overcoming barriers that exist outside the classroom.

Nor can it capture the relationships, personal growth, safety, extracurricular opportunities, and sense of belonging that make schools so important to their communities.

The implementation of this new accountability system also places additional expectations upon educators and administrators who are already navigating significant responsibilities with limited staffing and resources.

There is an uncomfortable contradiction in asking schools to produce greater results while simultaneously limiting the resources available to achieve those results.

Accountability without meaningful support risks becoming a system of identification rather than improvement.

If schools receive low ratings, what happens next? Will the state provide instructional specialists, targeted funding, intervention resources, professional development, and sufficient time to improve? Or will struggling districts simply be identified publicly and expected to solve increasingly complex problems with the same limited resources?

These questions deserve answers before the consequences of the new accountability system become entrenched.

Are we witnessing the gradual deconstruction of public education?

Perhaps my greatest concern is not any single policy decision, but the possibility that multiple decisions, when considered collectively, could fundamentally alter the structure of public education in Missouri.

Consider a hypothetical sequence.

State funding fails to keep pace with increasing operational costs. School districts become increasingly dependent upon local taxpayers to sustain existing programs. Additional accountability systems publicly identify schools as underperforming, even when those schools face substantial resource limitations.

Over time, financially vulnerable districts struggle to retain qualified teachers, maintain facilities, provide transportation, and offer the breadth of educational opportunities expected by the state.

Enrollment may decline as families pursue other options, further reducing revenues for districts already operating with limited financial flexibility.

Eventually, discussions emerge about financial viability, school consolidation, and the possible closure of smaller districts or individual school buildings.

Is this an inevitable outcome? Certainly not.

Is it a possibility that deserves serious consideration? Absolutely.

I am not suggesting that Governor Kehoe’s A–F report card is an announced plan to consolidate or close public schools. The documents establishing the framework do not demonstrate such an objective. However, we must examine how accountability policies could interact with persistent funding shortages, enrollment changes, and increasing operational demands.

For small rural school districts, the consequences could be especially significant.

School consolidation is often discussed through the language of financial efficiency. Yet schools cannot be evaluated solely through a financial spreadsheet.

When a rural community loses its school, it potentially loses far more than classrooms. It loses a major employer, a gathering place, a source of community pride, athletic and extracurricular traditions, and an institution that connects generations of families.

Students may face longer transportation routes. Families may become less connected to school activities. Communities may struggle to attract new residents and businesses.

The long-term consequences extend well beyond any immediate financial savings.

We should be cautious about creating circumstances in which consolidation becomes the only remaining financial option and then presenting it as a voluntary or necessary local decision.

The reality of operating a small rural school district

From the perspective of a rural superintendent, decisions made at the state level are not abstract policy discussions. They have immediate and lasting consequences inside our classrooms, offices, cafeterias, and school buses.

When state funding does not keep pace with rising costs, we cannot simply stop transporting students, heating buildings, providing special education services, or meeting the numerous requirements established by state and federal law.

We must continue operating.

The cost of transportation increases. Insurance premiums rise. Utilities become more expensive. Technology infrastructure requires ongoing investment. Facility maintenance cannot be postponed indefinitely. Qualified educators must be recruited and retained in an increasingly competitive employment environment.

Meanwhile, smaller districts often lack the economies of scale available to larger school systems.

A rural district still needs a superintendent, principals, teachers, counselors, nurses, food service personnel, transportation services, technology support, and specialized student services. Many of these responsibilities exist regardless of whether a district serves a few hundred students or several thousand.

When funding is constrained, smaller districts are frequently forced to make difficult decisions involving staffing, instructional materials, extracurricular opportunities, facility improvements, and employee compensation.

At Purdy R-II, we remain committed to providing students with a safe, supportive, and challenging educational environment. Our faculty and staff continue to demonstrate tremendous dedication, often doing more with less while maintaining high expectations for student achievement.

But dedication does not eliminate financial realities.

Passion cannot replace adequate staffing. Commitment cannot pay utility bills. Excellence cannot be sustained indefinitely through the continued depletion of financial reserves.

Our educators should be focused on improving student learning, not constantly wondering whether sufficient resources will exist to sustain the programs and services their students deserve.

The future of rural Missouri depends on the future of its schools

For generations, public schools have served as a foundation for opportunity in rural Missouri.

They have educated future teachers, farmers, business owners, healthcare professionals, skilled tradespeople, military service members, and community leaders.

They have provided children with opportunities that might otherwise have remained beyond their reach.

They have also represented something fundamental about our state’s commitment to its citizens: that a child’s opportunity to receive an education should not depend entirely upon the wealth of the community in which that child lives.

As we consider the future of public education, we must ask whether our current direction strengthens that commitment or gradually weakens it.

Accountability is important, but so is investment.

Fiscal responsibility is essential, but so is recognizing the true cost of educating children.

School improvement must remain a priority, but improvement requires more than identifying shortcomings.

And local control matters, but local control becomes increasingly hollow when local leaders have little financial flexibility to meet state expectations.

I believe Missouri can pursue higher academic standards, meaningful accountability, transparent governance, and responsible budgeting while also maintaining a strong commitment to rural public schools.

These objectives should not be mutually exclusive.

However, achieving them requires honest conversations about funding, policy priorities, and the long-term consequences of decisions being made today.

A final reflection: What are we willing to preserve?

As Superintendent of the Purdy R-II School District, I remain deeply committed to the students, families, employees, and community we serve.

Our commitment to excellence has not changed. Our belief in the value of public education has not diminished. Our determination to prepare students for college, career, and life remains unwavering.

Our theme for the 2026–2027 school year is ALL IN, and that is precisely what our faculty, staff, administrators, and Board of Education continue to demonstrate.

But being ALL IN should not mean that local school districts must carry an ever-increasing financial burden without adequate support from the state.

It should not mean that educators are asked to accomplish more while receiving less.

And it should not mean that rural communities are left wondering whether their schools will remain financially sustainable for future generations.

I believe we must have the courage to ask difficult questions about the direction of public education in Missouri.

Are we building a system designed to help every school improve, or one that increasingly distinguishes between communities with sufficient resources and those without?

Are we strengthening the state’s commitment to free public education, or gradually transferring more of that responsibility to local taxpayers?

And if continued financial pressures ultimately contribute to school consolidation and closures, will we recognize those outcomes as consequences of decisions made long before the doors were closed?

These are not questions of political affiliation. They are questions of educational opportunity, public responsibility, and the future of Missouri’s children.

The condition of public education today will help determine the condition of our communities tomorrow.

We cannot continue to raise expectations while diminishing the resources necessary to meet them and expect the system to remain unchanged. As a superintendent, I will continue to advocate for responsible stewardship, meaningful accountability, transparency, and the resources necessary to provide every child with a quality education.

Our students deserve nothing less. Our communities deserve nothing less.

And the future of public education in Missouri deserves more than another report card.

It deserves a sustained commitment to the schools, educators, and children who represent the future of our state.

Excellence is the Standard. But excellence requires more than expectations — it requires commitment, investment, and action.

Dr. Travis Graham superintendent of schools at the Purdy R-II School District. He may be reached at [email protected].

Create a free account, or log in.

Gain access to read this article, plus limited free content.

Yes! I would like to receive new content and updates.